Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Fajitas del Mar / Sea Fajitas
Bistec con Camarones / Steak with Shrimps
Fajitas de Camarón / Shrimp Fajitas
Bistec Especial / Special Steak
About
Cinco De Mayo
Welcome to Cinco De Mayo, a gem nestled in the heart of Sylvan Beach, NY. This vibrant Mexican restaurant has quickly become the go-to spot for locals craving authentic Mexican cuisine. With its friendly atmosphere and inviting decor, Cinco De Mayo provides not just a meal, but an experience that keeps diners coming back for more.
Located at 412 Main St, this establishment offers a diverse menu that celebrates the rich flavors of Mexico. From delectable tacos filled with carne asada and served with fresh pico de gallo to mouthwatering burritos wrapped in flour tortillas and drizzled with zesty salsa, every dish promises to delight your taste buds. The chalupas, featuring flat tortillas topped with beans, cheese, and guacamole, are a must-try; they offer a perfect balance of textures and flavors at an affordable price of $3.50.
- Chile Relleno: A poblano pepper stuffed with creamy cheese, priced at just $4.40, captures the essence of authentic Mexican fare.
- Children's Plates: Offering options like the Mexican Pizza, this eatery ensures younger diners enjoy a slice of Mexican culture.
Not only is the food extraordinary, but the service is exceptional as well. Numerous patrons have praised the attentive and friendly staff, creating a welcoming environment that makes every visit special. As Kelly Lasher noted, the quick service allows guests to savor their meals while leaving feeling satisfied and eager to return.
Customer reviews rave about the freshness of the salsa and the delicious warmth of the chips, which are notably seasoned to perfection. Diane Zeman-Marks encapsulated the spirit of this local favorite by declaring, "Just go, you won't regret it!"
With a commitment to quality, affordability, and outstanding service, Cinco De Mayo embodies the vibrant tradition of Mexican cuisine. Whether you're looking for a solo lunch, a family dinner, or a celebratory meal, this restaurant offers delicious options that cater to all appetites. Come and discover why this delightful establishment is fast becoming a beloved staple in the community.
Make sure to grab a seat at Cinco De Mayo and treat yourself to an unforgettable dining experience that intertwines the rich flavors of Mexico with the hospitality of Sylvan Beach.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ So happy to have local, DELICIOUS, and authentic Mexican. Our first visit brought a very friendly, attentive staff quickly served, hot, amazing food and super reasonable prices. The restaurant was clean and inviting and we cant wait to go back. We all left stuffed and hope they will be here to stay! ”
“ Prices are very reasonable, salsa was fresh, chips were hot with just the right amount of salt, food was very authentic and so flavorful,. Just go, you wont regret it! 5, very big, stars for this place!! ”
“ First time dining in and me and my son were the only ones there. Excellent service, the place was pretty cool inside too! Our food was beyond delicious and the chips salsa were to die for!! 1010 recommend! ”
“ First time there. And it wont be our last. My friend and I stopped for lunch after shopping. It was a birthday lunch. It wasnt busy sat right down and was given menu. There is alot to pick from. ... ”
“ This Mexican Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with exceptional food and topnotch service, making it a mustvisit spot ”
“ Food is so good, prices are nice and you get good amount of food. Place has a happy atmosphere, bar is well stocked, and everything is so clean and well kept. Servers are always nice, prompt and helpful. Been here twice, now my go to for real Mexican. ”
“ The food was incredible. I ordered an enchilada, chalupa, and quesadilla. The food was fresh and hot like it was just made. The food was very authentic, the atmosphere was great and the prices are very reasonable for home cooked food. The ... ”
“ The food was full of flavor. Absolutely delicious. The menu was a little overwhelming for someone like me who likes to try new things. It was hard to choose. Ended up getting the Burrito Jalisco deep fried burrito and the La mi patria which has three types of enchiladas. Yum! Finished off with deep fried ice cream. ”